Gold Forming Classic “Frowny Face” Pattern

Not to heap any more on the unfortunate gold bugs – their trouncing over the last few months has been rehashed in enough places (including here) that there’s not much to be gained from pointing out their woes yet again.

We just wanted to draw your attention to a chart pattern we’ve been watching as it has developed. Our charting may be a little rusty, but it appears that gold is forming the classic “frowny face” pattern:

Chart courtesy Finviz.com. Disclaimer: past performance is not necessarily indicative of future results.

Rather fitting, considering this is the face that most gold investors are probably making right now.

Smiling While Gold Sinks

If you’re a long-term trend follower, this is exactly the kind of move you like to see. A trend gets started in one month and – despite a few hiccups along the way – keeps moving lower and lower over the next 5 months, giving you time to get short…

Disclaimer: past performance is not necessarily indicative of future results.

And then one day:

Disclaimer: past performance is not necessarily indicative of future results.

A drop of more than $80 in a single day is huge… Every 1$ move in the price of an ounce of gold is a $100 change in the value of a gold contract. Anyone who stayed in a long gold position through it all is down $8490 per contract as of this writing (Disclaimer: past performance is not necessarily indicative of future results). And to think, it was just two days ago that Goldman Sachs recommended going short gold. In the annals of timely calls, that was a pretty impressive one. The online commentariat has been discussing this move at length, from the gloating naysayers to the chorus of gold bugs gnashing their teeth in frustration.

We don’t tend to get too deeply involved in that argument here. Managed futures isn’t a place where someone can get very far trying to argue over what gold should or shouldn’t do. Ritholtz posted a pair of great quips regarding gold today:

“Gold is a commodity, not a currency.”

And

“Gold is a trade, not a religion.”

We couldn’t agree more. And some of the CTAs we track are following that advice – Covenant Capital Aggressive has been short for months, and Quest Partners Original was short ahead of today’s move as well. We’ll see how much further gold has to fall, but those CTAs – and anyone who took Goldman’s advice earlier this week – are certainly smiling today.

Kicking Gold While It’s Down

Just two days ago we published a post pointing out that the decline in gold prices had caused the biggest gold ETF, the SPDR Gold Shares ETF (GLD) to fall below its 100-week moving average for only the 2nd time since 2004. But after seeing the “death cross” chart pattern (when the 50-day moving average crosses below the 200-day), the financial web exploded with pessimism for gold. Now we’re hearing about how hedge funds are fleeing GLD (Business Insider), the FOMC minutes are scaring gold bugs (Futures Magazine), and even the Economist is taking shots:

The current problem for gold is the same factor that helped fuel 12 straight years of price gains; there is no obvious way of valuing it. It has no yield or earnings. So gold bulls might be right to worry about inflation in the long run. But perhaps all those fears (and more) are already reflected in the gold price.

But with all the time and digital ink spent kicking gold in the last few days, gold futures are actually back up a bit this morning:

Chart courtesy Finviz.com. Disclaimer: past performance is not necessarily indicative of future results.

Did we just witness peak bearishness? Are we on the cusp of a mean reversion, or watching a dead cat bounce before the pessimists are vindicated by a further decline? Trend followers would enjoy a continued fall, so we’ll be cheering on the decline camp… and for the time being, it looks like that camp will be very crowded.

Platinum Outshining Gold in the New Year

With gold falling throughout the end of 2012 and platinum spiking more than 10% since the beginning of 2013, the change has been enough to bring the price of an ounce of gold below that of an ounce of platinum for the first time since April of last year.

Why do we care? Well, the spread between platinum and gold is instructive thanks to the many similarities between the two metals. For one, they’re neighbors on the periodic table of elements and have many similar properties; both are resistant to corrosion and often used in jewelry. They are both rare metals (though platinum is somewhat rarer) and roughly equivalent in difficulty of extracting from the earth.

The main difference from an economic perspective is that platinum has more industrial uses, which means it tends to be more influenced by the “real economy,” while gold has a far more prominent psychological factor in its price. (When’s the last time you heard someone advocate switching our monetary system to the platinum standard?)

So what does the recent price inversion tell us about gold or platinum? One data point does not a story make, so we compared the front month daily closing price of gold to that of platinum going back to 1982 to see how this relationship has fared over the last few decades:

Disclaimer: past performance is not necessarily indicative of future results.

The spikes in the chart definitely tell a story – platinum’s rise during the dot-com era and again during the ’04 to ’07 boom led to a historically low ratio. Economic crises have had the reverse effect, most noticeable in the massive spike in the ratio during the 2008 financial crisis.

In addition, the last year, with gold selling at a premium to platinum, is definitely unusual from a historical perspective. Over the 30-year history we examined the average ratio between gold at platinum was just below 0.8, meaning it would take a further 20% fall in gold prices relative to platinum just to get back to the historical average. And a return to the 2004-2007 levels would mean an even steeper decline of 50% in gold prices compared to platinum. Of course, this is only the spread, so such an outcome could occur through gold prices rising (but platinum rising faster) or by platinum prices falling (but gold falling faster).

That chart doesn’t give us a clear picture of how the relationship has fared more recently, so we also took closer look at the last two years, and added in a 200 day moving average:

Disclaimer: past performance is not necessarily indicative of future results.

We don’t pretend to be chartists, nor do we have a crystal ball to tell us whether this is a fake out lower or a real breakout that will take us back to the historical average spread between the two metals. There’s certainly a possibility of renewed crisis down the road (when isn’t there?) that could keep gold’s psychological premium over platinum alive and well, but this is one trade that, if it did revert to the mean, would definitely turn some heads.

Coinage Takes a Well-Deserved Nosedive

We had a good laugh around the office when CNBC started running segments about how awesome gold coins were. You would think that people would have learned since scams like Goldline have been exposed, but sadly, that wasn’t the case. At least… that wasn’t the case according to the pundits.  Marketwatch now reports:

The U.S. Mint’s gold-coin sales have fallen for a third straight year as the gold market undergoes big changes in its investment landscape to allow more choices for investors.

Sales of 753,000 ounces of American Eagle gold coins last year tumbled 25% from 2011, according to data from the U.S. Mint reported earlier this month. That was the lowest yearly sales total since 2007. In December, sales rose 16% from a year earlier, but fell 44% from the prior month. Read the WSJ story: U.S. mint gold-coin sales fell 25% in 2012.

At least investors may be growing more wary of gold coins as a means of investing in gold. Granted, gold coins from the US Mint aren’t really a bait and switch scam in the manner of Goldline… although they’re still going to be marked up somewhat compared to bullion or gold futures. And there are still a ton of investors who believe that gold is the answer to their prayers, even though the yellow metal has been demonstrating its typical volatility and tendency to cycle downward after a run up:

Chart courtesy Finviz.com. Disclaimer: past performance is not necessarily indicative of future results.

We know the general desire to own gold will never go away… no matter what the evidence against trying for a buy and hold gold position. In the meantime, we’ll take solace in knowing that investors have at least begun to shy away from the coin version.

Gold and Stocks Decoupling?

Gold futures have been getting hammered in the last few days (silver too) while stocks have been rebounding nicely back nearly to the 2012 highs we saw in September-October. Those who sold stock during the November slump and plowed into gold have definitely had a rough couple of weeks.

Looking at the charts, Business Insider (borrowing from Mark Dow) labeled this a breakdown in the correlation between gold and the S&P 500. This isn’t exactly a revelatory take. But the argument seems to imply that this is a break from the norm – that is, that this current move of Gold down and stocks up breaks a strong history of correlation between the two.

And this got us thinking… Watching the correlations between various asset markets is one of our pastimes, so we decided to check it out by looking at the rolling 30-day and rolling 250-day correlations between gold futures and S&P 500 futures (based on daily closing price):

You can see the 30-day correlation falling from above 0.6 to below 0.2 at the right end of the chart, showing how far that correlation has fallen in last month. (Disclaimer: past performance is not necessarily indicative of future results.) But looking at the bigger picture, it’s clear that the idea that there’s a strong historical correlation between gold and the S&P 500 isn’t supported by the evidence. The 30-day correlation bounces back and forth between extremes, while the long-term average tends to hang right around zero.

This year has sported a higher rolling 1-year correlation than at any point in the past decade, but it doesn’t hold up to argue that this represents a break with the longer-term trend. If anything, a sustained decline in the correlation between gold and stocks would be very normal, indeed.

The Best Way to Lose Money on Gold

In any election there’s going to be a sizable contingent that isn’t happy with the result. In the heat of the moment, some vocal losers may make some strong proclamations – in 2004 it was Democrats planning to move to Canada, this time around it’s Republicans petitioning the White House for the right to secede. In the end, it’s just a way of voicing disapproval, but it’s not like most people are actually going to follow through on the promises they make in the throes of political frustration.

But there’s at least one response to the election that is having a real impact: changing investment behavior. Those who fear the market will suffer under President Obama’s 2nd term are aiming to diversify their financial exposure away from equities. In general, diversification is a great idea, and this could very well turn out to be a prescient move – we don’t know anyone with a crystal ball who can say for sure. But what we can say is that many are going about it one of the worst ways we can imagine. Via CNBC:

Demand for gold coins in the US has soared since the presidential election, as small investors fret about the lack of action to address America’s ballooning debt.

The US Mint’s sales of American Eagles, one of the most popular gold coins, leapt 131 percent in November, hitting their highest level in more than two years. The Royal Canadian Mint also had its strongest month of sales this year.

Gold coins? Haven’t we been through this already? (The answer is yes, we certainly have)

The CNBC article does point out that coins are a relatively small part of the overall gold market, but for anyone in danger of being duped by the idea that gold coins are the best way to gain exposure to the yellow metal, we urge you to reconsider. There are some extremely shady dealers out there (Goldline, for one, but they’re certainly not alone). The peddlers of gold coins are notorious for bait-and-switch sales practices, and in our opinion, collecting gold coins should fall into the same category as collecting stamps or baseball cards: don’t bet your livelihood on it.

Even if you’re not getting ripped off by an unscrupulous dealer, why pay the markup on coins instead of just buying bullion? Diversification is great, and there’s nothing wrong with buying gold, but when you’re taking as much as a 40% haircut on your investment up front… This is one bit of election-driven nonsense we could do without.

Powered By Mow - Wordpress Popup Plugin