We had to double-check our calendars a few times today to make sure we hadn’t somehow traveled back to the summer of 2012. Back then markets were riding the risk on/risk off roller coaster thanks to fears that Greece’s elections would deal a catastrophic blow to Brussels’ efforts to hold the Eurozone together. Less than a year later, and we find ourselves watching the recent relative calm in the markets turned on its head thanks to the same fears – but this time, it’s thanks to Italy’s election.
As a quick recap: after former Italian Prime Minister Silvio Berlusconi (of bunga-bunga infamy) was essentially forced out of office last fall, the technocratic (and unelected) government of Mario Monti arrived. After few months spent implementing “Brussels consensus” policies to stabilize Italy’s (and by extension, the EU’s) debt crisis, Monti was extremely unpopular with a huge swath of the Italian public.
As a result, this weekend’s election had 3 major players: the center-left party of Peir Luigi Bersani; the center-right party of Berlusconi; and the populist anti-elite movement created by the comedian Beppe Grillo. Most of the world was hoping for a Bersani victory, which would essentially signal a continuation of Monti’s reforms. The morning’s news suggested a big win for Bersani, but that optimism was shattered once the vote counts started rolling in, and it quickly became apparent that Italy was probably headed towards an ungovernable gridlock.
And the ripples throughout the markets were enormous. The early morning rally collapsed into the biggest single-day loss of the year for US equities:
Chart courtesy Finviz.com. Disclaimer: past performance is not necessarily indicative of future results.
We witnessed a huge spike in the VIX while setting a new one-day volume record for VIX futures contracts:
Disclaimer: past performance is not necessarily indicative of future results.
The stalwart of safe-haven currencies – the Yen – saw a huge spike before settling back down somewhat:
Chart courtesy Finviz.com. Disclaimer: past performance is not necessarily indicative of future results.
We could go on (and on and on). The point is, Europe came roaring back into relevance thanks to Italy’s election results, and with it reminded us of those risk on/risk off news driven markets which per our recollection were disliked by nearly all market participants.
It will be a few weeks before we know whether Italy will be able to form a government, and if so, what that government will look like. But we don’t really care if they do or not. What we’re looking at is what this may do to the markets managed futures track. If this brings back the news-driven highly correlated market moves, that could spell trouble. If it is the start of a more substantial crisis, well – managed typically love a crisis and the outlier moves they bring.















A Mountain from a Mediterranean Molehill
You could be forgiven for thinking that the last few economic/financial “crises” haven’t felt very crisis-like. The dreaded sequester came and went without causing so much as a hiccup, and even the Italian election fiasco proved insufficient for more than a minor stumble in the market’s trajectory. But Europe seems intent on maintaining their new annual tradition of stirring up investor anxiety every spring. Enter: Cyprus.
Cyprus may be bigger than a molehill, but not by much. The fact that this much digital ink is being spilled worrying about a country with a GDP the size of mid-sized US city shows just how far we have to reach to find something dire to talk about these days. The country’s entire economy is a rounding error compared to the US federal budget…
Nevertheless, the airwaves are filled with concern that this could spark contagion, reignite the European debt crisis, and so on and so forth. Next verse, same as the first. At the end of the day, Cyprus matters precisely as much as people believe it matters, regardless of how much we think it ought to. And that means the possibility of choppy markets that have been the bane of many CTAs over the last several years.
But amidst the noise, we were pleased to see someone else who shared our frame of mind on such matters:
Sound advice in our book. Whatever comes of Cyprus, some prognosticators will be correct and some will be incorrect. But the traders with a sound system and solid risk management will be ready to capture a big trend if it arrives, or cut losses short if it doesn’t. Whether Cyprus causes just another ripple in the ocean or the tidal wave that the bears have been predicting for years – we’ll be glad we have our seat belt fastened.