Alternative Links: Is this what every Commodity trader looks like?

Commodity Trader“Behold the greatest piece of trading art ever created.  The piece is untitled, undated (likely from early 1970s) and by an unknown artist (Alfred Marshall), yet like the Mona Lisa it can be admired for it’s simplicity, intriguing facial expression and style which reflects upon it’s subject.  I hereby entitle it Smug Trader.” – (Trading Pit Blog)

We found this gem yesterday via Chicago Sean.

CTAs:

Rollinger explains Red Rock Capital Commodity Long Short Program – (Futures Magazine)

Managed futures June Performance – (Attain Capital)

Regulation:

Clearing houses to publish risk models – (Financial Times)

Education:

Asness: Why Investors Should Use Momentum Strategies – (Value Walk)

Buying the Managed Futures Drawdown – (Hedge Fund)

Managed Futures Podcast Series – (CME Group)

Allocation:

Mutual Funds Still Favorite Vehicle Of Choice For Alternatives – (Value Walk)

Managed Futures June Performance

After a bumpy start to the year, the average YTD performance of the 4 managed futures indices we track has managed to pull itself into the positive for the first time in 2014 {disclaimer: past performance is not necessarily indicative of future results}. Here’s the month by month performance of Managed Futures for 2014 thus far:

Managed Futures June Performance(Disclaimer: Past performance is not necessarily indicative of future results)
(Only 51% of returns reported to the BarclayHedge CTA Index)

Would you like some Volatility with that Pulled Pork

The ‘complacency everywhere’ meme has kept going as stock index markets continue to crawl higher, while bonds, energies, and other markets across the world just aren’t moving… (see here and here.) But there are a few places seeing volatility – you just have to know where to look. And where else would you look besides the notoriously volatile Hog market (haven’t you ever heard someone say pork bellies when you mention futures markets…) Well, the infamous Pork Belly contract is dead, but Hog volatility lives on in the Pig Virus that’s been sending Lean Hog Futures to all time highs.

As of March, the lean hog market had already experienced two limit up moves in the market, matching the total number of limit moves across 2009 & 2012. The USDA now estimates that the virus has infected 4,700 farms, 30 states, and killed more than 7 million piglets. In response, the USDA will spend $26.2 Million on a vaccine that will hopefully prevent the disease from spreading. That seems a bit of too little/too late with prices up so much this year, but better late than never, I guess:

Lean Hogs Market
(Disclaimer: Past performance is not necessarily indicative of future results)
Chart Courtesy: Finviz

And despite news of this virus hitting 14 months ago, the volatility has continued especially in the last three months, with 5 more limit moves (4 up, 1 down), bringing the 2014 total to 7; putting the Hog market at the most limit moves experienced in the last 6 years.

Lean Hog Limit Moves(Disclaimer: Past performance is not necessarily indicative of future results)

The best part about this volatility in the Hog market is that it has been directional volatility – meaning the expansion has been accompanied by a big up trend and that the large number of limit moves have been in the same direction. This is the type of outlier trade trend following models survive all of those flat and down months for, but unfortunately for the bulk of investors in trend following/global macro type models – they won’t see any returns from this move. You see, Lean Hog futures open interest of just 78,638 contracts (compared to 280,000 in crude oil futures  and 2,594,505 in 10 yr note futures) is generally considered too small for $1 Billion+ managers to access the space in any meaningful way.  That’s why we prefer smaller managers with greater commodity exposure, so they can access such moves.

Performance of 40 Futures Markets Mid-Year

We’ve officially made it half way through the year, meaning those who did well will likely be mentally doubling their first half success in imagining where their year will end, while those who struggled will act like a weekend golfer making the turn – saying ‘ok, let’s turn it around now… let’s get it done on the back nine’.

Without further ado, the front nine scores across 40 different futures markets courtesy of Finviz:

Futures Performance 2014 Q2(Disclaimer: past performance is not necessarily indicative of future results)
Chart Courtesy: Finviz.com

Some of our thoughts:

• 65% of the markets are positive of the year, down from 75% last quarter.

• Corn and Wheat went from number 4 & 8 on the leader board last quarter, to a negative performance on the year thanks to an ongoing multi-month down trend.

• Coffee and Hogs continue to hold their position as the top commodity performers. However, coffee is down considerably (-19%) from its 2014 highs, while hogs have been hitting new highs.

• Nikkei is the only stock futures index that remains negative of the year

• CHF, CAD, USD, and EUR are almost unchanged on the year

• The S&P 500 & the 30 Year Bond’s YTD performance are almost identical.

 

The Climate of Volatility, Investing, and Science

Some people have been saying Barry Rithotz’s writing has been going downhill of late (here), and we did like the old non-Bloomberg Barry a little better ourselves if truth must be told – but one of his most recent pieces is a peach, where he ties in volatility, investing, science, and climate change together. His basic message – don’t think about it as global warming, or even climate change. Think about it as a dramatic increase in the global climate’s volatility, what he calls Global Weather Volatility.  And don’t get caught up in the politics about it, get caught up in how to invest in it. As Ritholtz puts it:

I have but two goals: The ability to bet on global weather volatility, and a way to express the trade I like to call “short unscience.” As soon as I figure out how to do this, I am going to make a killing.

So how do you bet on Global Weather Volatility? How do you get in front of that trade? Buy (soon to be beachfront) land in the middle of Florida? Sell short the hurricane insurers?  Buy futures on agricultural crops like Corn, Wheat, Sugar, Cotton, and the rest?  Buy the CME’s stock in anticipation of more hedging and speculation on weather and the commodities it affects? And how do you go about shorting ‘unscience’?

First, is it Weather Volatility or Just More Weather?

Weather Bell Curve

The first problem with trying to go long ‘global weather volatility’ is what exactly does that mean?   The common perception is this means a greater number of  storms, more droughts, and so on. But technically speaking, that would mean ‘weather’ would have greater variations around its mean – not just greater numbers of events.  So we’re talking hotter hots and colder colds, dryer droughts and wetter floods, tons of hurricanes then no hurricanes,  polar vortexes and years with no snow.  Only time will tell, but we suspect most of the fears out there concerning climate change revolve around an increase in the number of events, not the variance in the number of events. It’s semantics, but hey… we review investment manager’s stats all day long, what do you expect?

So how do you bet on a wide variance of possible weather conditions season to season and year to year?

Do you add Sugar to your portfolio on news of dryness and hedge funds doing it?  No. Ritholtz pointed to a recent Bloomberg piece saying “hedge funds were betting on Sugar due to dryness” as evidence that portfolio changes are already being made in relation to climate change, but this is quite a ways off the mark in our opinion. For the most part, those hedge funds playing in the Sugar markets are managed futures funds (something we know a thing or two about), who are predominantly systematic. These systems don’t have coding built into the system indicating when to increase, or change positions based on a lack of rain. They aren’t adding long exposure because of climate change – they are adding it because prices broke above technical levels signaling an uptrend… Maybe that’s due to climate change – but it’s a stretch in our opinion to use that as evidence. And we wouldn’t recommend anybody try and play climate change by simply adding Sugar, or any other commodity, to a portfolio believing that it will go up because it will keep getting hotter or dryer or whateverer.

If it’s more Global Weather Volatility, that means we could have years with record droughts causing tight supplies and higher prices; and years with picture perfect growing conditions causing ample supply and lower prices. The more volatile the weather season to season, the greater the variance in the crop yields season to season. So just buying a commodity isn’t going to get the job done – as the differences from season to season become more severe – bringing more severe up and down price action with them.

So how do you bet on more volatility between crops and more severe up and down price action?

Barry was on the right track with the mention of Sugar, but we view that as evidence of weather moving commodity prices – and specific strategies setup to capture such moves; not evidence of investors betting on climate change. Whether it be Natural Gas prices responding the Polar Vortex, hundreds of thousands of Cattle dying because of an early winter storm in the plain states, or a plentiful corn crop recovering from a year of drought;  climate affects futures prices. Indeed, that’s the whole reason futures exist, for the farmers and consumers to be able to hedge their risk of such weather events spiking or crashing prices.

The problem is… how in the world can you know when the next weather event will happen, and whether (pun intended) it will affect prices, and which prices it will affect. Trying to predict which markets weather will hit next is a guessing game nobody could successfully navigate, and you won’t know which side of the trade to be on either. The only answer is to be in a broad cross section of these markets, with exposure to grains like Corn and Wheat, softs like Coffee and Cotton, meats, and the rest. And to be ready to trade either long or short in each of them, as the variations in the weather can either aid or hurt supply.  The only answer is a systematic approach which insures it will be in the outlier moves up and down by getting into every move, even the ones which don’t see any follow through.

Now, this strategy isn’t for everybody. For one, it doesn’t derive its return stream from the unemployment report, earnings numbers, or the latest tech IPO – so there’s very little to support your investment when you turn on CNBC every day.  Secondly, it is possibly the most frustrating strategy out there, being the antithesis of the consistent monthly returns investors yearn for. Trading such a systematic commodity strategy will be a string of fits and starts, of years of boredom followed by months of incredible excitement when outlier moves finally happen, and of multi-year losing streaks like is being seing right now in the managed futures space.

You see – it’s no mystery how to bet on Global Weather Volatility. You bet on volatility in commodity markets. You enlist a strategy designed to keep its powder dry and head above water during low volatility times,  while insuring it will be involved when volatility spikes – through accepting many small losers until the winner comes. Yes, we’re talking about managed futures, but trend following in particular, and commodity trend following in particular. It’s also long/short commodity funds, global Macro funds, and Ag traders – all of which have a long volatility profile.

What about the fact that volatility across asset classes is near record lows and these types of strategies have been at the bottom of the performance barrel over the last few years?  All the better.  Now we’re adding in some contrarian investing and breaking the performance chasing mentality as well. Where do I sign up?  (Here)

Weekend Reads

  • Japanese Investors Call Abenomics A Huge Success – (Valuewalk)
  • Hedge Funds Are Now a $3 Trillion Industry – (Barrons)
  • Wickr raises $30 million; investors include CME Group, Wargaming – (Reuters)
  • Are leveraged ETFs a threat to the industry? – (Investment News)
  • Climate Forecast: A Heat More Deadly Than the U.S. Has Ever Seen – (Bloomberg)
  • VIX trading available around the clock  — (Seeking Alpha)
  • Cracks In Market Chemistry – (J Lyons Fund Management)
  • When a ‘Liquid-Alt’ Fund Loses Steam – (Wall Street Journal)

Just for Fun:

Alternative Links: Taking the Fall

Taking the Fall:

“Indeed, the performance numbers (of the Yale Model) for the past 10 years make it clear that this model has failed to live up to its promise for a while, perhaps because there just aren’t enough good alternative investments to go around.” – Barry Ritholtz

Barry Ritholtz blames pension underfunding on alternative investments – (Ritholtz)

Regulatory:

Popular liquid alts funds face regulatory scrutiny – (Investments News)

U.S. House votes to loosen derivatives’ regulations with CFTC bill – (Reuters)

US CFTC appoints deputy director and chief counsel of the division of enforcement – (Hedgeweek)

News:

Equinox Funds teams with BlueCrest Capital Management to launch systematic macro fund – (Hedgeweek)

Education:

Back to (Managed) Futures – (Open Markets)

Alternative’ Mutual Funds: Different, Yes. Better? Not Lately. – (Wall Street Journal)

Futures & Miscellaneous

FX Futures Expand Overseas – (Markets Media)